|
In September of 2003 the CDC relaunched a program originally introduced
in 1995 called "Get Smart, Know When antibiotics work."
This is a 1.6 million dollar campaign targeted towards physicians
and patients to educate them on the proper use of antibiotics. The
purpose of this campaign is to reduce the amount of inappropriately
prescribed antibiotics in the hope of reducing the increase of antibiotic
resistant microbes. According to the CDC virtually all important
bacterial infections currently have resistant strains, making resistant
bacteria a crisis in the US and throughout the world. In 1995 The
AMA studied the issue of resistance and released the following statement:
"The global increase in resistance to antimicrobial drugs,
including the emergence of bacterial strains that are resistant
to all available antibacterial agents, has created a public health
problem of potentially crisis proportions."
Reports on antibiotic usage in the United States vary but estimates
put the numbers of antibiotic prescriptions written in the US at
anywhere from 100 to 250 million. According to Dr. Richard Besser
of the CDC there are currently tens of millions of unnecessary antibiotics
prescribed annually. The CDC reports that 90% of all upper respiratory
infections, including children's ear infections, are viral yet URI
account for 70% of all antibiotic prescriptions written. It is also
estimated that 41 million antibiotics are written for the common
cold annually. That comes to about $1.1 billion spent on antibiotics
just for cold viruses. There are about 7 million adult annual visits
to the physician for sore throats each year. Of these visits 90%
are for viral infections and yet 74% of these visits result in an
antibiotic prescription, typically a broad-spectrum antibiotic.
Unfortunately, of the some 40 million patients hospitalized each
year nearly 2 million of them will develop a nosocomial infection
and about 60% of these infections will involve antibiotic resistant
microbes. There are approximately 60,000 - 70,000 deaths per year
from nosocomial infections. The annual financial cost of antibiotic
resistance in the US alone is 30 billion dollars. These are staggering
numbers.
It seems fair to say that somewhere, someone is responsible for
such irresponsible prescribing, but whom? According to the CDC,
the AMA and several state health organizations the blame falls to
the patients and parents of the patients. In fact when doing a "Google"
search on antibiotic resistance for this article almost all searches
returned some references to patients demanding antibiotics from
their physicians. It is common phrasing that "patient demand"
for antibiotics is the cause of inappropriate antibiotic usage.
One hospitals website goes so far as to describe patients as "strong-arming
doctors" for antibiotics. Rarely, if ever, is the responsibility
focused on the physicians or medical organizations that regulate
physicians' standard of care.
I am of the opinion that this is the ultimate scapegoat strategy.
I have strong doubts some 100 million patients are storming their
doctor's offices "demanding" to be given an antibiotic
for a viral condition. In fact, I think most of us are rather intimidated
by our physicians and their starched white coats. Studies involving
patient satisfaction often indicate that one of the main complaints
patients have with their physicians is that they feel their doctors
don't listen to them. We are all familiar with the catch phrase
"god-complex" and know that it refers to physicians feeling
superior and certainly not subject to the "strong-arming"
of their patients. Just try disagreeing with your doctor about treatment
methods and you will quickly realize they are not being "strong-armed"
by the patients about anything.
|