Comments on: Miasms – an Overview http://hpathy.com/organon-philosophy/miasms-an-overview/ Homeopathy Medicine Portal for Homeopathy Doctors, Students and Patients. Homeopathic Remedies and Homeopathy Treatment information. Fri, 10 Feb 2012 08:23:01 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: Sheetal Kamblehttp://hpathy.com/organon-philosophy/miasms-an-overview/#comment-9977 Sheetal Kamble Sat, 10 Sep 2011 19:20:47 +0000 http://hpathy.com/?p=2382#comment-9977 Hi Manish, This article was really helpful to me. Thanks for posting this article Hi Manish,
This article was really helpful to me. Thanks for posting this article

]]> By: Hpathyhttp://hpathy.com/organon-philosophy/miasms-an-overview/#comment-2274 Hpathy Fri, 13 Aug 2010 02:29:03 +0000 http://hpathy.com/?p=2382#comment-2274 Hi Genevieve,Thank you for your kind feedback. Such feedback is what keeps us going month after month.This article was published in 2009 but was actually written much before that. I think I need to update it and add Grant's work too.I really look forward to reading your essay.Thanks a ton once again, Manish Hi Genevieve,

Thank you for your kind feedback. Such feedback is what keeps us going month after month.

This article was published in 2009 but was actually written much before that. I think I need to update it and add Grant’s work too.

I really look forward to reading your essay.

Thanks a ton once again,
Manish

]]> By: genevieve ahearnehttp://hpathy.com/organon-philosophy/miasms-an-overview/#comment-2273 genevieve ahearne Thu, 12 Aug 2010 23:04:40 +0000 http://hpathy.com/?p=2382#comment-2273 Hi Manish,Firstly let me say how indebted I feel to you and all the other editorial staff of this ezine: the professional calibre of your publication, and it's variety, breadth and depth, and its service re. bringing homeopaths into awareness of each other and what's going on in the field is brilliant. I read it head to toe every month.More specifically, thanks so much for this article. You have saved me a great deal of laboring (not that being forced to go back to the originals isn't always the best way to go about things, but your essay so succincty puts what my reading of various books threw up for me: AND, by the way, what a delight!to discover Ghatak's book (translated by Banerjee)which I have had sitting on my shelves for 17 years without opening: my mum was in Bombay in 1993 and bought so many books for me from Jain, that they threw it in as a freebie).I am currently re-writing an essay I wrote for myself on Grant Bentley's and Sankaran's use of miasms to 'diagnose'/'see' patients.I was a student of Grant's for a year, way back in 1995 (but was mostly trained by Mischa Norland in his correspondence course, and clinical training was at the Sydney School of Homeopathic Medicine. I use a combination of Mischa's and Sankaran's approach in my case taking/analysis). This past weekend I went to one of Grant's Facial Analysis seminars where he talked quite a bit about his Soul and Survival material/thinking on miasms.Which has prompted me to go back to my essay and expand it. (Grant, in my opinion, is shooting himself in the foot by making certain pronouncements about Hahnemann - due, in my opinion, to willfull picking and choosing of what Hahnemann said on the miasms. As I know Grant quite well, I know it is not because he is careless or can't read properly. I might write him a letter.) Anyway, it has helped my essay enormously to have your article to refer to.When I've finished my essay, I might send it to you: it might interest other homeopaths.Yours Sincerely,Genevieve Ahearne Hi Manish,

Firstly let me say how indebted I feel to you and all the other editorial staff of this ezine: the professional calibre of your publication, and it’s variety, breadth and depth, and its service re. bringing homeopaths into awareness of each other and what’s going on in the field is brilliant. I read it head to toe every month.

More specifically, thanks so much for this article. You have saved me a great deal of laboring (not that being forced to go back to the originals isn’t always the best way to go about things, but your essay so succincty puts what my reading of various books threw up for me: AND, by the way, what a delight!to discover Ghatak’s book (translated by Banerjee)which I have had sitting on my shelves for 17 years without opening: my mum was in Bombay in 1993 and bought so many books for me from Jain, that they threw it in as a freebie).

I am currently re-writing an essay I wrote for myself on Grant Bentley’s and Sankaran’s use of miasms to ‘diagnose’/'see’ patients.

I was a student of Grant’s for a year, way back in 1995 (but was mostly trained by Mischa Norland in his correspondence course, and clinical training was at the Sydney School of Homeopathic Medicine. I use a combination of Mischa’s and Sankaran’s approach in my case taking/analysis). This past weekend I went to one of Grant’s Facial Analysis seminars where he talked quite a bit about his Soul and Survival material/thinking on miasms.

Which has prompted me to go back to my essay and expand it. (Grant, in my opinion, is shooting himself in the foot by making certain pronouncements about Hahnemann – due, in my opinion, to willfull picking and choosing of what Hahnemann said on the miasms. As I know Grant quite well, I know it is not because he is careless or can’t read properly. I might write him a letter.) Anyway, it has helped my essay enormously to have your article to refer to.

When I’ve finished my essay, I might send it to you: it might interest other homeopaths.

Yours Sincerely,

Genevieve Ahearne

]]>