kbanhpathy

(@kbanhpathy) ?
active 1 week, 1 day ago
  • 2 months ago

    kbanhpathy

    kbanhpathy Posted a new activity comment 2 months ago

    Dear Sir,
    Nice u have come up to the help. The betrayal is not a delusion,happened so that among in her group of friends, she did things against the will of her friend circle and later they(her friends) insulted her and then she tells whom to believe,she feels betrayed.(can Ignatia come to the picture)

    In reply to - kbanhpathy posted an update in the group Understanding Rubrics This is a real case with the language in patients version: female-18+.Slim complaints start after an attack of malaria 6 months ago. Please suggest […] · View
  • 2 months ago

    kbanhpathy

    kbanhpathy Posted a new activity comment 2 months ago

    can i get some probable remedies from your expertise

    In reply to - kbanhpathy posted an update in the group Understanding Rubrics This is a real case with the language in patients version: female-18+.Slim complaints start after an attack of malaria 6 months ago. Please suggest […] · View
  • 2 months ago

    kbanhpathy

    kbanhpathy Posted a new activity comment 2 months ago

    this symptoms started after the attack of malaria. A loving child of both parents.No insults from either.

    In reply to - kbanhpathy posted an update in the group Understanding Rubrics This is a real case with the language in patients version: female-18+.Slim complaints start after an attack of malaria 6 months ago. Please suggest […] · View
  • 2 months ago

    kbanhpathy

    This is a real case with the language in patients version: female-18+.Slim
    complaints start after an attack of malaria 6 months ago.
    Please suggest me in rubric hunting and pointed remedies.
    the version of patient full rich in mental qualities:Starts:
    “I feel that whom i trust is betraying me, feel i have no value in this earth,there is no god…[Read more]

    • ruchi shirudkar 2 months ago

      delusion betrayed she is, pessimist, confidence want of self confidence, reproaches self, brooding, company desire for.
      i feel these are all expressions of patient we need to understand the cause. i mean why she has gone in this state? little detail history needs to be taken

      • kbanhpathy 2 months ago

        this symptoms started after the attack of malaria. A loving child of both parents.No insults from either.

        • kbanhpathy 2 months ago

          can i get some probable remedies from your expertise

          • Mrinal Mohapatra 2 months ago

            Nat. Mur. & Nat. Carb. I ll prfer Nat. Carb. first.

          • Manish Bhatia 2 months ago

            Lyco is another remedy that you can think abt but the thermal of both Natrum and Lyco does not match your patient, i.e if the thermal is marked in your patient.

    • Manish Bhatia 2 months ago

      It needs to be ascertained that what she is saying about betrayal is a ’delusion’ or ’truth’ about her life. Was that Malaria the only event or were there actualy other changes in relationships at the same time?

      • kbanhpathy 2 months ago

        Dear Sir,
        Nice u have come up to the help. The betrayal is not a delusion,happened so that among in her group of friends, she did things against the will of her friend circle and later they(her friends) insulted her and then she tells whom to believe,she feels betrayed.(can Ignatia come to the picture)

        • Manish Bhatia 2 months ago

          If betrayal is not a delusion but something that happened to her in reality, then we will not take the delusion rubric. Rather the ‘reaction’ to the situation becomes more important now.
          What is the reaction? Is it grief? Is it resentment? Is it frustration? Is it jealousy? guilt? Which one is predominant? Cross that with the physicals…[Read more]

  • 2 months ago

    kbanhpathy

    kbanhpathy Posted a new activity comment 2 months ago

    u can see ”open repertory” listed in reverse materia medica under chapter abdomen. It’s true in most cases that if generals agree particulars play no role except if the symptoms are rare & peculiar.

  • 2 months ago

    kbanhpathy

    kbanhpathy Posted a new activity comment 2 months ago

    yes if symptoms agree. gelsemium is listed for colic in abdomen

    In reply to - kbanhpathy posted an update in the group Understanding Rubrics i was going through various repertories:found something about rubrics can any one clear 1. nose-coryza – fluent- eup-per 3 2. nose discharge – watery- […] · View
  • 2 months ago

    kbanhpathy

    kbanhpathy Posted a new activity comment 2 months ago

    thank u drofart.good touch, we must try to treat acutes first with accuracy.why people tell to ban homeopathy in australia the news is a grave one isn’t it?this is because that homeopaths fail in treating acutes with good accuracy.it’s just like give the dog a bad name and kill it.

    In reply to - kbanhpathy posted an update in the group Understanding Rubrics i was going through various repertories:found something about rubrics can any one clear 1. nose-coryza – fluent- eup-per 3 2. nose discharge – watery- […] · View
  • 2 months, 1 week ago

    kbanhpathy

    i was going through various repertories:found something about rubrics can any one clear
    1. nose-coryza – fluent- eup-per 3
    2. nose discharge – watery- eup-per do not figure out.
    what is the difference between fluent and watery? suppose a patient tells that i have watery dischage form my nose and my limbs have aching pain. i have fever and feel…[Read more]

    • Mrinal Mohapatra 2 months, 1 week ago

      Fluent : smooth and unconstrained(free from constraint[retard something's motion]) in movement.
      In easy free flowing without interruption, used when there is a modality present to fluent flow otherwise “constant” is used.
      Watery : Nature resembles to water. Touch it no thickness, no slippery feeling.

      Discharge can be watary, fluent watery,…[Read more]

    • kbanhpathy 2 months ago

      thank u drofart.good touch, we must try to treat acutes first with accuracy.why people tell to ban homeopathy in australia the news is a grave one isn’t it?this is because that homeopaths fail in treating acutes with good accuracy.it’s just like give the dog a bad name and kill it.

      • Mrinal Mohapatra 2 months ago

        The problem is What is acute & what is acute phase of chronic disease. LOL !!
        My success in pure acute diseases is getting better by following Predictive homeopathy pt-2.
        P.S- Only with this book ! no you cant :x

        • Suji 2 months ago

          I have read this book here the dr. said about activity,thermal,thirst and mental axis. based on this 4 points u can get the similimum . Each axis has a few number of remedies. There few remedies like lyc,sepia etc which are deep acting and no aconite like short acting remedy which is generally used in acutes.
          Can the deep acting remedies be given…[Read more]

          • kbanhpathy 2 months ago

            yes if symptoms agree. gelsemium is listed for colic in abdomen

  • 2 months, 2 weeks ago

    kbanhpathy

    i have seen that general symptoms either mental generals or physical generals lead to a curative action!
    can anyone classify in more depth the general physical symptoms.
    1. suppose if i feel lassitude and feverish- is it a general or particular.
    2. My limbs are aching-general or particular.
    3. My disharge from sexual organs are fetid-general or…[Read more]

Groups

Members