Materia Medica Course on Shameless Remedies with Dr Manish Bhatia
Clinical Cases

Menses Absent/Suppressed

A useful article about Menses Absent/Suppressed.Full details about Menses Absent/Suppressed

(October 2006)

Female aged 24 years presents with menses absent for 3 months, she is not on the pill and has been off it for some months as it bloated her, made her put on weight and feel generally unwell when she was on it. She has had pregnancy tests to ensure that she is not pregnant. She has been checked by a gynecologist and told that she may have endometriosis (early stages). Her family, on her father’s side have a history of endometriosis, in fact most of her female cousins have had hysterectomies by the age of 35 years and they also have had difficulty conceiving.

Her periods have always been difficult, irregular and painful. Her abdomen often is distended and bloated…, “it feels hard as a rock, then it feels like a knife is cutting through it”. She is also prone to being very emotional and reactive, especially around the time of ovulation and before her period is due. She is very sensitive to what people say and gets hurt very easily and can also be very jealous with boyfriends. She seems quite soft and yielding in her approach in the clinic.

She is in an unhappy relationship with a guy who was quite controlling. Her relationship with her mother is quite frayed as she is really controlling about her life, boyfriends and career. Her mother’s interference with her performing career makes her not want to try but she still wants her approval and feels very vulnerable around her as she makes her feel down and not good enough when they speak. She gets upset every time she calls her and feels quite depressed and a little sick.

She can only eat plain foods as anything too rich upsets her stomach. She often has wind and it can feel ‘stuck’. She feels worse after she eats if she takes a big meal. Her teeth break easily and one has never come through in the front, so she has had them filed to make them match.

She had her appendix removed at age 4. She has vivid dreams often about sex or they can be frightening and violent. She says that every boyfriend that she has ever had, although they have never been aggressive to her, they always get into fights when they go out. Her current boyfriend had had an incredibly violent upbringing. She says that although her mother is quite volatile and scary when angry there was not real violence in her childhood but she remembers being very afraid when she made her mad. She can not understand why she draws people like this to her because she is not like that.

I chose the following rubrics using Murphy:

  • Female, Menses, suppressed (pg 673)
  • Mind, mild, disposition (pg 1373)
  • Mind, humiliation, ailments from (pg1345)
  • Dreams, amorous, sexual dreams (pg 451)
  • Abdomen, Cutting, pain (pg 12)
  • Food, eating, after, agg (pg734)
  • Food, fat, food, agg (pg 736)

Facial Analysis

YELLOW (psora)
RED (sycosis)
BLUE (syphilis)
  • Front teeth prominent
  • Freckles
  • Straight hair line
  • Single line
  • Large eyes
  • Mouth brackets
  • Wide mouth
  • Gums
  • Curved forehead
  • High hairline
  • Wide set eyes
  • Teeth
  • Dimples
  • Asymmetry ears/mouth

Miasm – Syco-syphilis – Purple

Of the purple remedies most prominent were: Bell, Hyos, Lach, Plat, Staph, Stram and Nit Ac.

I chose Staphysagria 200 single dose (07/10/06) mainly for the mental picture this patient presented, she was so sensitive and affected to the point of being controlled by other people and their opinions of her and so easily humiliated. She seems to be surrounded by violence although not violent herself but more yielding.

She got her period 8 days after the Staph 200 (after a 3 month absence). A week later she ended her relationship and moved out of their shared house.

I saw her 5 weeks later (16/11/06) and she felt as though the period was coming but hadn’t arrived, so she took another dose of Staph 200 and it arrived 2 days later. She was still very happy with her decision to end her relationship and happily out having fun. She has been a lot more light hearted and content with her life.

February 2007

Her cycle is now at about 30 days, she is in a new relationship which to her seems “like a remarkably normal relationship not as full of angst and jealousy as her previous relationships”. The bloating is much better as is the PMT and pain.

She is also amazed at how she has managed to come out from under her mother’s controlling influence. After years of stop/start attempts, hampered by others trying to control her, she is independently working on her passion of performing. She says it is the first time she has just gotten on with it, with out telling anyone or the need for constant support/direction from family or partners. She seems to be more at ease with herself, and laughs far more easily even in conversation. She says that people have noticed the change in her and it feels like it is for the better.

The interesting thing is that her new boyfriend is a very gentle and supportive partner but he plays sport at a national level, this sport is one of the more aggressive ones. The energy of violence is still there around her but in a controlled environment, she finds when she is watching the sport she cannot get over how violent it is!

About the author

Natalie Russell

Natalie Russell

1 Comment

  • Natalie I have been trying to find you. Someone said you are working in Selby but I have looked on the net and can not find you as I wanted to make an appointment. Please email me your details at the above email address.

Leave a Comment