Materia Medica Course on Shameless Remedies with Dr Manish Bhatia

France Falls to Pharma

Editorial July 2019

The Swiss government’s report on homeopathic medicine in 20111,2 was the most comprehensive study on homeopathy ever conducted by a government, lasting six years. It concluded that homeopathy was effective, safe and economical and sometimes worked even better than conventional medicine. It recommended that homeopathy be incorporated into the Swiss national healthcare system.

Fast forward to France 2019, where you have to read between the lines to follow the intrigue. Agnès Buzyn was promoted from President of the ‎Haute Autorité de Santé (HAS) (health regulatory agency), to Health Minister in 2017. She subsequently asked her former subordinates at the HAS for their opinion of homeopathic medicine. After a cursory review, they recommend that homeopathy be withdrawn from France’s national health care system. Buzyn then announces that she’s just following the advice of HAS, and, as of January 1st, 2021, homeopathy will no longer be reimbursed. Got it?

The individuals at the HAS, none of whom had studied homeopathy, nor read any of the thousands of cured cases, nor reviewed the roughly 3000 clinical studies and research papers that exist on homeopathy3, nor interviewed any homeopathic doctors, nor even taken a remedy, decided, after nine months, that homeopathy was just placebo. This, in spite of the fact 72% of the French people believe homeopathy has benefits, and, as homeopath Dana Ullman has pointed out, “ a survey found that 95% of French pediatricians, dermatologists, and general practitioners use homeopathic medicines. Further, 43% of ALL health and medical professionals in France prescribe homeopathic medicines for their patients.”4

Shortly after the HAS announcement, shares in the French homeopathic pharmacy Boiron, the largest manufacturer of homeopathic medicines in the world, were suspended in trading. Boiron now stands to lose 60% of its yearly income. It is not incidental that this story was reported in the Bloomberg News, a major world reporter of financial news.5 So, the plot succeeds.

We’ve seen similar assaults on homeopathy by government agencies in Italy, Spain, Australia, the U.S. etc. The attacks are choreographed by corrupt government officials at the highest levels. Their tactics include specious studies, disinformation campaigns in the press, slandering public figures who support homeopathy (eg. Prince Charles, who recently became a patron of the Society of Homeopaths) and the undermining of homeopathic pharmacies through government regulations and nuisance law suits.

Homeopathy, and the rest of holistic medicine face a critical moment. Huge grassroots movements are needed to push back against this. The millions of people who use homeopathy and other natural healing methods, as well as anyone who treasures freedom, need to decide whether they want the right of choice in medical care, or a society dictated by Pharma, which profits from their sickness.






In This Issue:

–  EDITORIAL  – France Falls to Pharma – Alan V. Schmukler

–– Feedback Letters from June 2019 –


— Dr. Harry van der Zee is interviewed by David Nortman

Dr. Harry van der Zee MD is an international teacher and has presented seminars world-wide. He served as editor in chief for Homœopathic Links for 22 years, authored books on miasms and birth trauma, and co- founded the ARHF to help prevent epidemics in Africa.


– Online Homeopathy Course by George Vithoulkas

– Lectures on Organon of Medicine VOL 2 by Dr. Bhatia – AVAILABLE NOW!


––  Crohn’s Disease and Autopathy – Jiri Cehovsky

––  Rheumatism is a Woman of 68 – Dr. Ajay Pandey

–– Acute Vertigo in a Man of 52 – Dr. Rajiv Peres

––  PCOS in a Woman of 24  – Dr. Sonal Sinha

––  Palpitation in a Man of 51 – Dr. Vasudha Vij

––  Four Acute Cases – F. Joan Macdonald

–– Male Infertility / Chronic Rheumatism  – 2 cases  –  Petr Zacharias                 

––  Alopecia Areata in a Woman of 32 – Dr. Nikunj Jani

–– Cyclic Vomiting Syndrome  – Dr. J. Michael Xavier

––   Wet Eczema & Chronic Depression – Dr. Bhuvaneswari Jayashankar

––  Severe Hair Loss –  Drs. Juhi Malhotra & Gaurang Gaikwad


––  Homeopathic Management of Renal Colic -with cases – Dr. Navin Pawaskar, Dr. G .Chand Sharma    

––   Homeopathy – A Sri Lankan Odyssey – Dr. Vaish Sathasivam LCH  

––  Obstacles to Cure – When Surgery is Really Necessary -Judith Acosta

––    Dr. Mohinder Singh Jus – An Indian Legend – Dr. Rajiv Peres

–– The Soul of Remedies –  Argentum Metallicum –– Dr. Rajan Sankaran

––  Journey of a Homeopath –  Dr. Sheetal Bidri

––   Disorders of Nails and Homeopathic Remedies  – Dr. Medha V.

–– When Patients Bring Tears to Your Eyes – Dr. Aparna Joshi

––  How to Study Allen’s Keynotes – Dr. Gaurang Gaikwad

–– TIDBITS 65  : The Scary Operation (Elaine Takes Over As Dental Surgeon–Again!) – Elaine Lewis

–– TIPS & SECRETS – Alan V. Schmukler


–– Healing Cancer: A Homeopathic Approach (volume I and II) – by              Dr. Farokh Master, is reviewed by Vatsala Sperling, PhD, RSHom

–– Glyphosate Free – An Essay on functional nutrition and the homeopathic clearing of glyphosate toxicity. by Kate Birch, RSHom, is reviewed by Rochelle Marsden, RSHom


–– ASK THE HOLISTIC VET – July 2019 – Dr. Deva Khalsa


–– CROSSWORD June 2019 – Alan V. Schmukler


––  Targeting Homeopathy  – Alan V. Schmukler


–– What Remedy is Emily Gilmore (and Her Mother-In-Law)? – Elaine Lewis, Shana Lewis

–– Revisiting:  Ahem! Ahem! Ahem!!! — Elaine Lewis, Shana Lewis


–– THE PLANT DOCTOR – July 2019 – Radko Tichavsky

About the author

Alan V. Schmukler

Alan V. Schmukler is a homeopath, Chief Editor of Homeopathy for Everyone and author of ”Homeopathy An A to Z Home Handbook”, (also in French, German, Greek, Polish and Portuguese). He is Hpathy’s resident cartoonist and also produces Hpathy’s Tips & Secrets column and homeopathy Crossword puzzles each month. Alan is a recipient of the National Center for Homeopathy Martha Oelman Community Service Award. Visit Alan at his website: Here.


  • Alan, what a horrifying editorial! Big Pharma is no joke! Boiron losing half its income? Yikes! The holistic health movement needs to radicalize, like the ’60’s, and get out there and march! I wish the Royal Family would start making some noise!

    • Yes, I agree totally. We’re long past responding to attacks by submitting more research. The people attacking homeopath already know it works! That’s why they’re attacking it! We need a massive bottom up movement. Prince Charles just became a Patron of the Society of Homeopathy. Within a few days he was attacked in the press for siding with homeopathy.

      • Yes, I know, “more research”, what a joke! There will always be something “wrong” with whatever research we do; or, they just continue to lie about it! “There’s no research! No studies!” And yes, they know it works, that’s why they’re acting the way they do! The last thing they’re interested in are therapies that work!

Leave a Comment