Homeopathy Papers

6 Reasons Why Homeopaths Should Not Practise Allopathy

Last modified on January 29th, 2018

Firuzi Mehta
Written by Firuzi Mehta

Homeopath Dr. Firuzi Mehta presents her view on “Why Homeopaths Should Not Practise Allopathy”

As a homeopath, I oppose the bridge course which is being contemplated for practitioners of homeopathy and other AYUSH (Ayurveda, Unani, Siddhi and Homeopathy) streams. The bridge course will allow AYUSH practitioners in India to practise basic conventional medicine. Here are my thoughts on this and I write it from the point of view of homeopathy being my field of medicine:

  1. We have a very effective and strong system of medicine ourselves, so why do we need to prescribe conventional medicine? In an emergency, if life-saving conventional treatment is needed (if the homeopath is not skilled or confident enough of treating it), patients can go to trained doctors in that field. The bridge course is not going to provide high-level ER training in any case.
  2. It is said that the reason the government is planning this move is because there are insufficient doctors in rural areas and people living in such places have no access to healthcare. Fine. Why does rural India need conventional treatment only? Why can’t the other systems of medicine be practised there? In fact, this is a good chance to show, in comparative terms, how the other systems of medicine contribute positively to healthcare.
  3. This bridge course is not going to help the cause of AYUSH. As students and young practitioners, many want to practise conventional medicine because of status and the perception of higher incomes. It is also a fact that to be a good homeopathic physician, one needs a great level of skill which only comes with hard work and constant learning. It is not as easy as prescribing ‘this for that’. Hence, this bridge course will serve as a back-door entry to conventional medicine practice and will be an escape route to avoid putting in the effort needed to be good homeopaths. Over time, this will reduce the number of skilled homeopaths and will be a dangerous matter for the future progress of our system of medicine. I presume the same would be the case for the other AYUSH streams.
  4. Pharmaceutical companies will be very happy at the increase in their profits by getting lakhs of more practitioners who will prescribe their medicines.
  5. As it is, conventional medicines unfortunately have loads of side effects. We regularly see patients in our practices, who come for problems and actual diseases that have arisen due to some side-effects of conventional therapy. It is possible that the AYUSH practitioner will be easily blamed for every side-effect that a patient suffers from. The side-effect will be attributed, not to the chemical drug which is actually responsible, but to a lack of skill in the AYUSH practitioner.
  6. As a final point, let the Government ensure that every student receives good training and practical experience before they venture out as physicians. Let every physician develop the skill, and practise the field of medicine they were trained in. As homeopaths, let us not forget that we have the possibility of doing great things to improve the lives of our patients, bringing cure in so-many problematic chronic cases, and yes, we have the ability to be life-savers as well, if sufficiently skilled in our science. And this satisfies the soul. Isn’t it worth it?

About the author

Firuzi Mehta

Firuzi Mehta

Dr. Firuzi Mehta qualified in homeopathic medicine in 1997 and then completed her HMD from the British Institute of Homoeopathy, London. In 1998, she also attended an Introductory Course in Anthroposophic Medicine and Iscador Therapy for Cancer at the Lukas Klinik in Arlesheim, Switzerland now known as Klinik Arleshim. After working for over 5 years with an eminent homeopath in Mumbai, to gain work-experience, she started her own practice in 2001. She reviews homeopathic books as and when the opportunity arises and firmly believes that one's knowledge is always incomplete and needs to grow. She is currently enrolled with—and studying for—the 2 year E-Learning Programme offered by Prof. George Vithoulkas' International Academy of Classical Homeopathy. http://www.homoeopathie.in

5 Comments

  • Firuzi, very good! There is nothing quite so useless as an allopathic education, as you will use it maybe 10 percent of the time, with homeopathy covering the rest–that is if you hang around long enough to get a proper education in it, as you pointed out!

  • Thanks Dr firuzi for your post.I want to know why a homoeopath will be lured to prescribe allopathic medicines? we have our own scope as well as limitation like any other system of medicine We should do our best as homoeopath only.

  • If medical doctors of systems other than conventional medicine are allowed to practice conventional medicine, they are digging their own grave. In the long run, they will meet the same fate as Ayurveda and ayurvedic doctors had in India.

    Legally, Ayurvedic doctors are allowed to prescribe life-saving drugs only but those practising actually are prescribing many more drugs. Slowly over the decades, they lost the art and science of Ayurveda. The great science of Ayurveda from which modern day surgery is evolved. Homeopathy will meet the same fate if it goes the Ayurveda way.

    I will consider it as a welcome news if homeopaths are not allowed to practice allopathy.

  • If allopathy is allowed to be practiced by homeopathy practitioners, they stand to make more money. This may dilute the knowledge they have of homeopathy, down the road they will not be able to practice homeopathy at all. Two systems with opposite thinking cannot coexist. You suppress the very symptoms that you depend on for your diagnosis and you cannot recognise the healing procedure which is necessary for the process to continue when the two systems are used simultaneously. It will definitely lead to poor diagnosis and poorer recognition for homeopathy. If there is a definite way to to kill homeopathy, THIS IS IT. It will only help those who have taken to homeopathy just because they could not get a seat in a medical college of the allopathic system or the ones who are just there to make more money.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *