Clinical Cases

Revisiting: Come Fly With Me!

flying wallendas

Looking back at last month’s quiz. Did you get the right answer?

Who remembers last month’s quiz? I’ll repeat it here for those of you who didn’t see our last issue:


To read last month’s full case quiz. Visit – Come Fly With Me!


So, how well did we do? Almost everybody got that this was an Arnica case. The real test was, would you have known what potency to give? Only one person said Arnica 10M–congratulations go to Dr. GOPAKUMAR G of India!  Good for you, sir!

You know, when you have a severe injury or acute like this, your 6C’s, your 30C’s are practically useless! You see how 15 minutes after the accident the boy was reclining and calmly watching TV? That shows that the potency chosen was absolutely spot-on! This is what your high potencies are for–sudden, severe mishaps, infections, frights, animal bites, burns, medical emergencies, psychotic episodes, mania, hallucinations, violence, suicidal disposition, etc.

You wouldn’t want to start your chronic cases off this way, if someone has been sick for years, and on Rx drugs, you have to approach this person gingerly.  He’s sure to lack the stamina and vitality of a healthy child who’s fallen off his bike.

Almost everyone got that the topical cream was Calendula. A few said Hypericum, that’s good too. However, it’s almost a moot point, as Calendula cream often comes with the addition of Hypericum and you can scarcely buy the two separately!  For instance, I have here, Nelson’s “Hypercal” cream and I also have Nelson’s “Cuts & Scrapes” which, again, is Hypericum and Calendula together; though I do have Boiron’s “Calendula Ointment” which is just Calendula. Everyone knows that Calendula is for accidents involving broken skin, and especially for what is called “road rash”, which is where you’ve been dragged along the pavement and your skin is severely scraped. Dr. Dorothy Shepherd has an almost identical case to this one which she writes about in her book, A Physician’s Posy:

“A young man was knocked off his bicycle and dragged along the ground on a gravelly pavement. The skin was rubbed off his face, nose, eyebrows and palms of his hands; his face and hands were like raw pulp. Arnica was given repeatedly, Calendula tincture applied in dilution–result: perfect cure in a few days, no scarring and of course, no tetanus and he was back at work in three days!” (Kelly’s son was back at school in three days!)

Now we come to our last question which was, what was the remedy which was given frequently starting on day-2? No one got this, so I’m glad we came to hear this case because now you’ll know! The remedy was Calendula 30C. Most people aren’t aware that Calendula comes in potency and most first aid kits don’t have it! Again, here is Dorothy Shepherd:

“You can strengthen the action [of Calendula] by giving it internally as well, Calendula 6, 12, 30 in repeated doses until healing has taken place. It acts on the epithelium and promotes the rapid growth of normal cells. … I have said several times, Calendula is similar to clean operation wounds and cuts; not only for local applications but do not forget to give it potentized by the mouth as soon as the operation and the effects of the anesthetic are over. It will hasten the healing process. … Another doctor who sings the prowess of Calendula is Dr. Petrie Hoyle, the American doyen of homeopathy. He used it extensively in the war hospital he superintended in France during the 1914-1918 war and the visiting French surgeon complimented the doctor on the cleanliness and sweetness of the air in his wards. ‘There were no cloying sickly smells of antiseptics about,’ he said, and moreover, he complimented him on the exceedingly low mortality and the quick recovery rate of the wounded. … Calendula is not an antiseptic in the true meaning of the word, but it is a fact that germs do not thrive in its presence, it inhibits their growth and even if wounds are already badly infected, I have seen offensive, purulent discharges become clear and sweet-smelling in a day or two. … Unashamedly I confess, I am not afraid of germs, not even tetanus, and sepsis has no terrors for me. Arnica is applied in contusions, sprains and even fractures, where the skin is unbroken, both externally and internally. Calendula or Hypericum lotion is applied to cuts, abrasions, clean and dirty wounds; even ulcers, abscesses, local carbuncles, all get treated with either Calendula or Hypericum. Calendula I reserve for clean wounds, and they do not go septic; Hypericum is perhaps more applicable for already infected states. … I get no erysipelas, no pyemia, no septicemia and no tetanus. And many of the cases i have seen were already heavily infected with staphylococci or streptococci. Also they get on rapidly and heal more quickly than in the old days when i followed slavishly in the footseeps of my surgical teachers and used the antiseptics of the day.”

So, I think we’ve perhaps said enough about Calendula. Aside from our above winner, N. Rezai of London came very close with Arnica 1M, Hypericum LM/1 and Calendula cream; “Anonymous”, always a big winner here, came close with Arnica 1M, Symphytum 30C (“injuries of the face”–D. Shepherd) and Calendula cream and Dr. Kashmira Patel came oh-so-close with Arnica 1M, Ruta 200C (she was probably thinking of injuries to the face too) and Calendula cream. Let’s call them all winners!

Dr. B, what prizes have they won?


This month’s winners will get a special 30% discount on one order of books from Hpathy Mall.

Click Here for Prize Guidelines

Elaine Lewis, DHom, CHom.  Elaine takes online cases. Visit her website at:

About the author

Elaine Lewis

Elaine Lewis

Elaine Lewis, D.Hom., C.Hom.
Elaine is a passionate homeopath, helping people offline as well as online. Contact her at [email protected]
Elaine is a graduate of Robin Murphy's Hahnemann Academy of North America and author of many articles on homeopathy including her monthly feature in the Hpathy ezine, "The Quiz". Visit her website at: and

Leave a Comment