Clinical Cases

Answer to Case # 2 of case solving contest: ‘The ‘Fasten Seatbelt’ Sign Makes Me Feel Trapped’

A useful article about Answer to Case # 2 of case solving contest: ‘The ‘Fasten Seatbelt’ Sign Makes Me Feel Trapped’.Full details about Answer to Case # 2 of case solving contest: ‘The ‘Fasten Seatbelt’ Sign Makes Me Feel Trapped’

Sonia S, a tall, willowy Latina woman with large deep eyes and a beautiful wide smile, came to see me complaining of “bursitis, joint pain, tiredness. Joint pain began in graduate school when I ran into an old boyfriend on vacation.”
She continues, “My foot pain started then, and shortly thereafter my hip pain, and I have had it ever since. Wet weather aggravates it, and when I travel for work on airplanes. First thing in the morning it hurts, then it begins again in the afternoon around 2 or 3 pm.” She is now 30 and the joint pain began when she was 25.

She rarely remembers dreams, none are recurrent. She weeps easily premenstrually but not the rest of the time. Her fears vary, usually worrying about day-to-day issues at work. Others see her as a perfectionist, controlling at times, and as someone who worries too much. She says she gets stressed easily, with her biggest stress work-related (finding work she likes; she currently works as a consultant.) She gets angry when stressed. She also gets angry when things don’t go as she expected them to. She gets jealous when her husband spends a lot of time talking to his old girlfriend, or to her best friend.
She describes herself as a child as being happy, active, and very social. If she had time off from work, she would like to travel, visit a city she has never been to before and go dancing. What she would like to change about herself: would like to be more easy-going while still having energy and excitement.

Her only medication is birth control pills. She gets a mid-cycle vaginal discharge that is clear, thick and sometimes white.
She dislikes beets and says of her diet only, “I could eat more vegetables.” She likes room temperature drinks and sleeps from 10-11 pm to 6-7 am. She gets canker sores in her mouth, and her jaw sometimes cracks.

When I met her, I was struck by how beautiful, smiling, friendly and outgoing this woman was. I asked her first to give me more details of her joint pain: she said when she went out to San Diego and ran into her old boyfriend, her right ankle hurt, then her left knee and hip (possibly from favoring her right ankle, she said); then it spread to the left ankle and right knee and hip. She has been to a physical therapist to strengthen her leg muscles but still lacks range of motion in her ankles. She has been diagnosed with bursitis of the hip and has been to an acupuncturist. Acupuncture left her feeling calmer and more relaxed but did not help her joint pain.

The joints feel worse in damp weather and worse when she first gets up in the morning, then better as she starts to move around, then worse towards the end of her workday because she has been zooming around all day trying to get things done. They are worse when she flies especially when she goes to Europe. She can’t bear sitting still and tries to keep walking up and down the aisles. It’s hard for her when the Fasten Seatbelt sign goes on and she has to sit down, cramped in the small seat. Traveling is also difficult when she has to carry heavy luggage because she gets worn out. Stretching helps, but exercising too much makes the joint pain worse. A hot bath makes it feel better.

Once she seemed comfortable in the interview, I asked her more about what happened in San Diego. She said that she had a boyfriend from the age of 16 to 21 while living here in the Boston area, then she broke up with him. When she was 25 she went to visit a friend in California and by an unbelievable coincidence, this ex-boyfriend turned out to be the roommate of the friend she was visiting. It was an uncomfortable situation, in fact the young man was quite nasty, “agitated and not nice.” He mentioned that he had a gun.

She became convinced that he would come back to Boston, find her and kill her. (Upon questioning, though, she admitted that he had not actually made any threats.) She was so afraid that he would kill her that she moved to an unlisted address, using a PO box for forwarding, and had an unlisted phone number which she gave only to her family and a few close friends. When she got married two years ago, she would not allow her wedding announcement to be published in the paper, because she did not want him to know where she was or what her married name was. Even though this incident happened five years ago and she is now married, they still have an unlisted number.



This is a Rhus tox case. While taking the case, of course I kept thinking of Rhus tox because of all the typical modalities of the joint pain. However, I usually think of Rhus tox as an acute remedy, not as a chronic remedy that can cover the totality of the client’s case including mental-emotional symptoms. When she got to the part about believing her ex-boyfriend wanted to kill her, that confirmed Rhus tox on all levels – it is the classic Rhus tox delusion about being murdered. It was clearly a delusion on her part, as it was influencing her behavior even years later, to the extent that she still had an unlisted phone number. The client did very well on Rhus tox, which cleared up all her joint pains. She referred her husband for homeopathy a

Characteristic symptoms:

bursitis, joint pain

in lower extremities
< wet weather
< first thing in the morning
< 2-3 pm
> moving around
< sitting still
< exertion (luggage)
> hot bath
> stretching but < too much exercise

controlling, perfectionist

gets angry when things don’t go as expected

other symptoms

easy weeping premenstrually
worries excessively, work-related (an argument could be made that this is a common symptom and therefore not characteristic to her)
canker sores
jaw cracks
believes ex-boyfriend wants to kill her even though he did not say so

Other possible themes: restlessness, overgrowth/excess

Rubrics could include (there are many variations)

K1047, Extremities, pain, joints
damp cold weather
exertion, after
K1048, Extremities, pain, joints
warmth amel.
K1063, Extremities, pain, lower extremities
morning on rising
move, beginning to
K1066 Extremities, pain, lower extremities
sitting, while
weather, wet
K1191, Extremities, stiffness
morning, bed, in
rising, after
rising, on
K1192, Extremities, stiffness, joints
on rising
sitting, while
K1193, Extremities, stiffness, lower limbs

These subrubrics are small and so could be combined

K45, Mind, fear, happen, something will
(or better yet in Synthesis, Mind, fear, control, of losing)
K16, Mind, conscientious about trifles (= perfectionist)
K29 Mind, delusions, murdered, he will be
K94 Mind, weeping, menses, before
K397, Mouth, aphthae (= canker sores)
K357 Face, cracking in jaw, when chewing (she didn’t actually say when chewing, but that’s the only repertory option for jaw cracking)

Rhus tox not only covers the joint pains and the delusion, it also covers the cracking in the jaw. The only other remedy we might think of for her is Phosphorus, which covers her outgoing nature and her love of dancing and travel. She may have a Phosphorus consitution underlying the Rhus tox layer caused by meeting the ex-boyfriend, however Phosphorus does not cover the joint pains which are so characteristic of Rhus tox.

About the author

Begabati Lennihan

Begabati Lennihan is director of Teleosis School of Homeopathy in Cambridge, MA. A Harvard alumna, she practices homeopathy at the Lydian Center for Innovative Medicine and teaches meditation at Harvard Health Services"™ center for mind-body medicine. She is an Adjunct Instructor in homeopathy at Massachusetts College of Pharmacy and has edited several textbooks of homeopathy.

1 Comment

  • nice prescription..nice analysis…but one can also think of calc.phos as underlying constituion, calc also being a complimetary to rhus tox.
    1) The other symptom block that come to mind are those of puls.(fearfullnes,submissiveness,mildness,premestrual tearfulness,etc), and thuja as an intercurrent remedy cosidering the clino-pathologico-miasmatic coorelation. of course rhus tox cleared the case, but u never know when and what block u will face while dealing with any case

    2)Please also mention the potency selected..and repetation.. to make things more clear..
    thank you

Leave a Comment