Master Case Taking with the Masters Course

Revisiting: Toothiness

Shana smiling in profile @ Sabrinas

Elaine gives the answer to last month’s quiz.


Mom, it’s time for the October quiz!

Not to worry, Shana, I am totally prepared this month! As luck would have it, I have experienced yet another toothache!

Mom, do people really care about toothaches?  I don’t think anyone wants to hear it!  Wouldn’t my runny nose be more interesting?

Shana, puh-leeze take your Nat-mur and go watch TV!  Isn’t the Rug Rats on?  Now where was I? Ah yes! My unbelievably interesting toothache! It was a beautiful autumn day as I remember… the birds were chirping, the crickets were singing…. Horns were honking, sirens were blaring…. Plumes of poisonous greenhouse gases were spewing forth from the oil refineries nearby, and I, yes I, began to take notice of an irregularity emanating from the tooth about which I wrote last July.

Mom, no one remembers that!

I thought you were watching TV!  Now, as I’m sure everyone remembers from the July ezine, the molar on my lower left side had begun to hurt; specifically, touching the top of the tooth was very painful and I had very little hope for holding on to that tooth until Pyrogen performed yet another homeopathic miracle for me! Now, fast-forward to one month ago. I was totally minding my own business, as usual, when gradually I felt an “incident” brewing in that same tooth! I didn’t worry because I “knew” that all I had to do was repeat the Pyrogen and I’d be fine! I did, and wasn’t!

If there was ever any proof needed that every case is different, this was certainly it!  After Pyrogen didn’t work, I became suspicious and checked to see if I had the same tooth sensitivity on the top of the tooth as I did last time, and, in fact, no, the sensation from last time was not there. I looked in the mirror and there it was, big as life — a huge swelling of the gum on the facial side! “Oh my God, an abscess!”

Well, I took out Murphy’s Repertory and went to Mouth: abscess, gums (it’s the first rubric in the Mouth chapter) and took, probably, over the course of two days, most of the 3’s and even one of the 2’s from that rubric, and….nothing!!!!!!

I was in despair. I just knew I was going to have to go to the dentist and probably have the tooth pulled. I remember even doing the time-honored rinsing with hot water and salt to no avail; in fact, it may have even made it worse! “That tooth’s nothing but trouble!” I said.

Then I did something strange. I decided to touch the abscess. What was I thinking??? What was I hoping to accomplish? But you know what? The most bizarre thing happened. I was taken aback by an unexpected sensation: that of a very fine needle going in–Ouch!  It stung!  How strange and shocking! I was totally unprepared for that. Shocked, I tells ya! I expected a sore sensation only! But as this was so peculiar and characteristic, I immediately went for a dose of _____________30C and viola! In a short time, I could feel the pain going away!

The next day I repeated the remedy in a 200C, as I didn’t think the 30 was doing all it could, and I was rewarded with even more improvement. Ultimately I went up to 1M and that finished it off. I’m sitting here right now with no signs of that horrible ordeal whatsoever, feeling perfectly normal! And by the way, do you have all your first aid remedies up to 1M? The 30C works well, but not always, so, don’t try to save money by thinking you’ll purchase these potencies when you need them, get them now! In fact, I was quite relieved to discover that I had this remedy in the 10M if I needed it, but luckily I didn’t.


So, how did we do this time? Here are the vote totals below:

Nitric Acid 8

Silica 6

Hepar sulph. 4

Thuja 3

Apis 3

Spongia 2

Nux v. 2

Petroleum 1

Mercury 1

China 1

Agaricus 1

Lachesis 1

Kali carb 1

As no doubt all of you can see, Nitric acid and Silica were big favorites. By the way, let me just add here the following: Oddly enough, by the time you read this, the election here in the United States will be over, meaning that as you’re reading this, I am either jumping for joy, shouting, “Obama won! Obama won!” or jumping off of a balcony. And now back to our show. So, we have three winners this month! Yes, three people guessed that the remedy that felt like a needle going into the gum on pressure was, Apis! I mean, that’s what a bee sting feels like, right? That was my first thought, so I went with it. As a confirmatory, remember my saying that I tried the hot water rinses and they did nothing except for possibly making me worse? That would certainly go for Apis; and secondly, isn’t an abscess a swelling, much like a bee sting? Well, it totally worked, I have been fine ever since. Maybe we need to add Apis to the “Mouth: abscess, gums” rubric, with a subrubric, “needle-like pain, hot water agg.”

So, who were our winners? Congratulations go to: Jitka, Eli and Lucio! Oh Dr. B….. where are you?


This month’s winners will get a special 30% discount on one order of books from Hpathy Mall.Click Here for Prize Guidelines

Elaine Lewis, DHom, CHom.  Elaine takes online cases. Visit her website at:

About the author

Elaine Lewis

Elaine Lewis, D.Hom., C.Hom.
Elaine is a passionate homeopath, helping people offline as well as online. Contact her at
Elaine is a graduate of Robin Murphy's Hahnemann Academy of North America and author of many articles on homeopathy including her monthly feature in the Hpathy ezine, "The Quiz". Visit her website at: and

About the author

Shana Lewis

Shana spices up the Hpathy Quiz with her timely announcements and reviews on the latest in pop culture. Her vast knowledge of music before her time has inspired the nickname: "Shanapedia"!

Leave a Comment

Homeopathy for Everyone
Learn homeopathy with the world's greatest experts every month - for FREE!
World's No.1 Homeopathy e-Journal - for the community, by the community.
No Thanks!