Propaganda 101 from Lille University School of Medicine

Written by Alan V. Schmukler

EDITORIAL  September  2018

 Homeopathy has a long history in France, and today it is widely used and hugely popular. To illustrate this, in 2003, 62 % of French mothers used homeopathic medicines 1 and 94.5 % of pharmacists helped pregnant women select remedies.2 Most of the pharmacy schools teach homeopathy, as do seven medical schools.  Twenty-five thousand doctors prescribe the remedies.3 Oscillococcinum is one of the best selling flu remedies in France.

In spite of that, Lille University School of Medicine, the largest medical teaching center, suspended its Diploma of Homeopathy program for the 2018-19 academic year. The diploma has been in existence for 30 years, and those teaching the course were never consulted about the decision. This was the result of an open letter to the newspaper Le Figaro, signed by 124 healthcare practitioners, calling for a ban on alternative medicines.4 The dean of the Faculty of Medicine, Didier Gosset, declared:

“It has to be said that we teach medicine based on proof – we insist on absolute scientific rigour – and it has to be said that homeopathy has not evolved in the same direction, that it is a doctrine that has remained on the margins of the scientific movement, that studies on homeopathy are rare, that they are not very substantial….”

Every homeopath reading that statement, along with the millions of lay people who have been cured by homeopathy, will recognize all the falsehoods in it.  It is conventional drugs that are not based on scientific rigor.  The drug testing process is performed by the drug companies, and is fraught with corruption. Test results are often falsified to hide side effects, and the drugs are constantly recalled for causing injury or death.  On the other hand, most basic research in homeopathy, including provings, is done by people who have nothing to gain but knowledge.  Homeopathy is affirmed by hundreds of excellent studies done with people, animals, plants and in vitro.5   Cases cured by homeopathy number in the tens of thousands, spanning 200 years.

It strains credulity that the dean of Lille University School of Medicine, could be totally unaware of all this.  Rather, this latest attack is part of the worldwide, orchestrated assault on homeopathy that has already occurred in the UK, Spain, Italy, Australia and the US.  It is carried out secretly by Pharma surrogates who, nevertheless, are rather easy to identify.  In the press, it will be the editor of the magazine or paper. In government, it will be the head of the regulatory agency, and in academia, the official who would remove homeopathy from the curriculum.  You can readily find their names.

Next time you read an official attack on homeopathy, you’ll know who’s been compromised.  Let them know that you know who they really work for.

(1) Transactions, Nutrition Business Journal, July 7 2004.
(2) Damase-Michel, C., Vie, C., Lacroix, I., Lapeyre-Mestre, M., Montastruc, J.L. Drug Counselling in Pregnancy: An Opinion Survey of French Community Pharmacists, Pharmacoepidemiol Drug Saf. 2004 March, 18;13(10):711.

(3) https://www.huffingtonpost.com/dana-ullman/homeopathic-medicine-euro_b_402490.html

(4) http://www.lefigaro.fr/vox/societe/2018/03/18/31003-20180318ARTFIG00183-l-appel-de-124-professionnels-de-la-sante-contre-les-medecines-alternatives.php?redirect_premium


In This Issue:

Interview – Paola Brown is interviewed by Alan V. Schmukler – Paola Brown is the President of Americans for Homeopathy Choice (HomeopathyChoice.org) and a passionate activist for homeopathy. She’s currently challenging the U.S. FDA’s attempt to ban homeopathic remedies.


Repertory Round-Up, part 6– Elaine Lewis

– The Acute Prescription -Making it Easier Part I – Dr. Shrikant Talari

– The Soul of Remedies -Staphysagria – Dr. Rajan Sankaran

The Quantum Dynamics of Homeopathic Succussion -Christina Munns

– Freedom of Choice – Balance in Medicine – Gill Graham

– A Second Look at the Database Provings.info – Jörg Wichmann

– Research in Contemporary Culture – Why Words Matter – Part I –          Loretta Butehorn

– The Many Faces of Psorinum – Dr. Arshi Tank

– Insight Into the Mind Chapter of Lesser Known Remedies – Dr. Abhishek Choudhary

– Concordance – Remedy Relationships – Dr. NeerajaKshirsagar

TIPS & SECRETS  –  Alan Schmukler & Dr. Sneha Thakkar


– Anxiety in a Man of 17 – Petr Zacharias

– Autism in a Child of 3 – Drs. Prajakta Vaida&Preety Shah-Chauhan

– Daily Urticarial Patches in a Boy of 3

– Venous Ulcer in a Man of 48 – Dr. Pravin Pente

– Pyrexia of Unknown Origin – Dr. Rajiv Peres

– Bell’s Palsy in a Woman of 55 – Dr. Bhanu Sharma

– Perennial Allergic Rhinitis – Dr. Rajni Mishra

– Different Cases – Different Approaches – Dr. Gaurang Gaikwad

–  Headache of 10 years and Cough in a Child of 3 – Dr. Shishir Paranjape


– Argon – by Jeremy Sherr is reviewed by Rochelle Marsden.


– September 2018 – Ask the Holistic Vet – Dr. Deva Khalsa


– New Horizons in Water Science – Seminar at Royal Society of Medicine – Jacqueline Smith


– Crossword September 2018 – Alan V. Schmukler



Elaine  Lewis

-Revisiting:– Elaine  Lewis


– The Plant Doctor – September 2018 – RadkoTichavsky

About the author

Alan V. Schmukler

Alan V. Schmukler is a homeopath, Chief Editor of Homeopathy for Everyone and author of ”Homeopathy An A to Z Home Handbook”, (also in French, German, Greek, Polish and Portuguese). He is Hpathy’s resident cartoonist and also produces Hpathy’s Tips & Secrets column and homeopathy Crossword puzzles each month. Alan is a recipient of the National Center for Homeopathy Martha Oelman Community Service Award. Visit Alan at his website: Here.


  • This is not unexpected. For homeopathy literally it’s a case of “too many cooks spoiling the broth” .
    We have umpteen masters promoting their own individual methods but none of them anywhere equalling the time tested Repertories ( even there’s a lack of knowledge about how to use them). In fact they are all inconsistent with one another.
    If sensations method is true, repertory can’t be true, if Kingdom method is correct everything else should be defective and so on.
    Actually homeopathy would have been better off and has retained its respect if none of these numerous inconsistent methods were promoted and tolerated by hapless homeopaths the world over.
    Let us stick to the age old and reliable methods of Prescribing and discard all doubtful and unscientific modern methods.
    Let us be worthy of the saying “Aude sapere” in the real sense.

  • Homeopathy has been used for thousands of years. It existed in Ayurveda far before Hahnemman was born. It has no side effects and even if there are minor ones another remedy can correct this.
    Conventional medicine was made for money reasons and bear no resemblance to our bodies. These are poisons only suppress symptoms and not cure. In the long run they have to poison our bodies with chemicals it is not familiar with and doesn’t know what to do with them.
    The British when in India closed down all the Ayurvedic schools to promote their own conventional medicine.

  • Editorial on behaviour of traditional medical institution towards alternative medicine especially Homoeopathy has been biased since long. In 2017 UK NHS put a ban on prescribing homoeopathic medicines on the premise that i has no scientific backing in treatment of diseases.
    I personally feel we homoeopaths are also equal resposible for this.
    In our institutions it is not taught as to how patient data be saved and presented. In Germany I visited Dr. Reckweg
    and learnt that their R No series are only can be marketed if we provide data of at least 250 patients for each R. No. and every four years data is supplied to concerned authorities for approval to sell it in Germany that too only below 6x potency.

    Can we persue such strict patient data collection to prove our view point?

Leave a Comment