Homeopathy Book Reviews

Absolute Homeopathic Materia Medica. Authentic Desktop Guide by Drs. P. Ishwardas Tarkas and Ajit Kulkarni – Reviewed by Dr. Joe Rozencwajg

Written by Joe Rozencwajg

Absolute Homeopathic Materia Medica. Authentic Desktop Guide by Drs. P. Ishwardas Tarkas and Ajit Kulkarni is reviewed by Dr. Joe Rozencwajg, NMD.

B. Jain Publishers Ltd.
ISBN: 978-81-319-0110-6
Softcover. 1220 pages.
Reviewer:  Dr. Joe Rozencwajg, NMD.

Why would I want or be interested in yet another Materia Medica? Don’t we have enough of those sitting on our bookshelves? And especially one named after a vodka? (Absoluut if you did not get it…).

I was intrigued by comments made about this one being different, modern, more oriented towards the clinic and very much down to earth… but only 150 remedies for more than twelve hundred pages, not a characteristic of a desktop guide.

I was not disappointed.

The Materia Medica of each remedy is divided into three parts: Generals, Particulars and Relations.

The Generals are subdivided in categories:

  • The “Monogram” which is basically the “signature” of the remedy: a collection of a few words that characterise the remedy, a very schematic picture of it whose purpose is to give at first glance an idea about what we are dealing with. This hits the target, most of the time; there were some remedies (I did not read all of them, I must admit) where I asked myself “where did they get that idea from?”, but this is probably linked to limits to my knowledge and the experience of the authors.
  • Region-Worse-Better: that is pretty clear; three subcategories linked together: mostly a tropism towards certain parts of the body, certain functions or systems, like Boericke, Phatak and Vermeulen wrote, followed by aggravations and ameliorations.
  • Highlights is the “essence” of the remedy, e.g. Arnica’s highlight is Injury and Bruising.
  • Action, the action of the remedy either from provings or from clinical results or from toxicology, which allows us to understand why a specific remedy is working the way it does.
  • Make-up is basically the good old “constitution”, a concept that is understood and used differently according to various authors.
  • Nerves is the collection of “nervous” or neurological problems like weakness, spasms, convulsions, pains, numbness, paralysis and more; those are generally found under the different sections of the body, where they will appear again, but are usefully put together in one single place.
  • Tissues is quite similar to “Regions” but with more precision: blood, bones, muscle, glands, nail, cancer and more, allowing the practitioner to check whether the remedy would have a more specific focus; this can sometimes be a very important point of differentiation between a few remedies, especially if they have been selected through other, more esoteric systems.
  • Ailment from is clear and does not need commenting.
  • Mind is the Mind rubric that has been moved here. It covers the mental symptoms and dispositional characters as well.

Particulars include the old Hahnemannian listing from Head to Skin, without the Mind that has been moved up, and the thermal state where the rubrics of chill, heat, sweat and fever have been put together.

Relations focusses on comparative materia medica, where one can see how other remedies would fare in a case and may be direct towards considering another remedy that might be more precise. The authors have introduced many new words, when compared to other comparative Materia Medicas.

At each step, comparisons with other remedies are given in brackets, sometimes with comments or clinical tips, removing in my case the feeling of reading a catalogue or a phone book while trying to understand a remedy (and often falling asleep during the process), replacing it with “Lightbulb moments” of enhanced interest, renewed learning and cortical stimulation.

Fair to say this book has achieved its purpose but has a few limits: I was looking for Sepia; not there; then for Silica: not there; but Bartfelder is included… never heard of that one and some others, yet it must have been used frequently and with success by the authors. Clearly, we need and expect a few more volumes written in the same vein.

Other than frequently used remedies, is there something else missing?

A repertory, with rubrics rewritten and based on those three parts and their subcategories.

A very deep and serious proofreading! Too many typos! And rarely a few sentences do not make any sense at all. I consider that this book should find a place of honour in every homeopath’s working space; therefore, it deserves the utmost care in presenting itself as being of high quality at all levels and not botched up during printing.

To my fastidious mind, this is not acceptable and is an insult to the authors. I have been assured by one of the authors (A.K.) that a new edition has been fully proofread and all needed corrections made.

That being said, just buy the book, you will not regret your investment!

About the author

Joe Rozencwajg

Dr. Joseph (Joe) Rozencwajg, MD, PhD, NMD, OMD was born in Belgium in 1951. After medical school, he went on to fulfill his childhood dream of becoming a surgeon. He subsequently learned Acupuncture, Homeopathy, TCM, Nutrition, Flower Remedies, Aromatherapy, Naturopathy, Reiki and other modalities. He has a PhD in Homeopathy and one in Natural Medical Sciences as well as a Doctorate in Naturopathy and one in Osteopathy. Dr. Joe lives in New Plymouth, New Zealand where he practices exclusively Natural Medicine at his clinic, Natura Medica Ltd. He developed a entirely new series of homeopathic potencies and is the author of numerous articles and the books :The Potency. Advanced Prescribing in Homeopathy, Homeopathy through the Chinese looking glass: Homeosiniatry revisited,. Dynamic Gemmotherapy and, Drainage, Detoxification and Organotherapy. His books are available from www.lulu.com Visit Dr. Rozencwajg at his website: www.naturamedica.co.nz

Leave a Comment