Feedback

Letters to the Editor January 2007

Letters to the Editor January 2007

Dear Manish
Your editorial is excellent and very positive concerning the animosity of conventional medicine.
I am afraid that we not any more in danger from the Academic Medicine but from our own ranks!
It is very said for me to hear all the crazy nonsense that is going on in so called “homeopathic” teachings!

Best regards,
George Vithoulkas

—————————————-

Your site Hpathy is by far the most valuable and positive oriented web site for the homeopathic community.

Have a wonderful new year and great success!
Warmest regards

Dr Luc De Schepper

———————————————-

Dear Elaine

I enjoyed your article [Christmas Catastrophes!] in Hpathy where you listed your favourite remedies for gastric distress. I note that you did not mention my favourite remedy Nat Phos 3x which I always prescribe to help this problem and wonder if you have used it. I have used some of the remedies that you mentioned but discovered that they were not as effective as the NP.

I have helped many chronic cases of GERD which were being treated by H2 blockers with the patients using Nexium and equivalent drugs for a long time who discovered that within about a week on Nat Phos 3x and Arnica 30 that they were soon relieved of their hyperacidity and did not want any drug or remedy any more to keep them comfortable. I believe that the Nat Phos helps to accelerate the progress of the food into the gut and thereby prevents the formation of the hyperacidic condition which promotes GERD. The Arnica helps to rebuild the eroded tissue of the esophagus and the Lower Esophagal valve which it usually does in a few weeks.

You may like to know that I have a few very old patients who depend on Nat Phos 6x to help them to have a daily BM as some of them were dependent on laxatives including paraffin to do so. The dosage they use is just 2 tablets after 2 meals and their reaction to the first dose is that they feel very comfortable after a meal and do not suffer from the gastric distress that they used to suffer from with loss of appetite and inability to have a daily BM.

Happy Christmas to you.

Kind Regards

Joe

————————————-

Dear MANISH,

After some days spent away, I just received your messages. Wonderful job this last December issue. I have already read it on its diagonal, including your very interesting article. Maybe, I could suggest some answers for your questions, but, before all, please remember the logic of AND / AND…
From a biophotonic (energetic-informational) perspective, the DNA IS LIGHT penetrating the liquid crystal structures, by generation a dextrogyre helicoide… So, its structure could be modified in time, somehow, by the “light” of the illness / microbes / bacteries etc. or of the homeopathic remedies too… AND / AND…

Congratulation, my dear friend, for all your professional work, for your enthusiastic involvement into a common task: to make this world be more harmoniously.
In this way, please consider myself as being one’s of your team.
Staying in touch for the next steps, please receives my best wishes for
A LIGHTLY MERRY CHRISTMAS and for A HAPPY NEW YEAR 2007.

Affectionately yours.
Traian

————————————-

December issue being an issue concerning on research, I am more convinced of Nov issue articles by Alex Hankey and Kate because they speak of the system and medicines and also the article ‘The Immateriality and Material Alchemy of Homeopathy’ by Melanie Grimes in the magazine interhomeopathy.org in Dec. issue. Al l other articles or interviews are connected to actual application of the medicines which vary according to individual patient who is treated or person who treats Also they are approached as if Homoeopathy system is like that of other systems of medication which I find is not so. Homoeopathy system itself is towards understanding life principles as told by Malanie Grimes and repetition can be done only according to individual patient of which I have sent articles seperately.
Regards, K.V.Natarajan

————————————-

Homeopathic Facial Analysis Dec 2006 ezine article.

Wonderful reading. I agree 100% with these two authors regards the importance of miasmatic predominance in a casetaking should include not only the symptomology,pathology,history,mentals/emotionals,desires… ……but the physical aspects of each patient to analyse miasmatic traits.I have mentioned it before in my posts on “in person ”casetaking VS ON line casetaking.It is a big part of the visual communication a homeopath needs.

“CARSINOSINUM”.by Philip Bailey is another great example of this type of miasmatic analysis,he includes many color/clear photographs of carc. types.

The entire physical body is a road-map, visually touring our final choices as to the well indicated miasm/or miasmatic layers.This obviously must include the face.

Gina Tyler

————————————-

Surviving Xmas Hols

Can I just say what a brilliant article this was by Elaine Lewis – everyone should read it.

I’m going to save it and keep it as it’s not just for Christmas.

toots

————————————-

Homeopathy is alive & kicking

You’re so very true about that. Here in Egypt we are facing a lot of arguments about Homeopathy, at the same time lots of people are searching for Homeopaths and Homeopathic remedies, both are forbidden by the ministry of health in our country.

sherinenabih

————————————-

Dear Manish

This months issue was quiet interesting

In connection with NMR measurement of biophotones in homeopathic medicines it would also be interesting to reconsider the work of Dr Grimmer and Dr Abrahams. If not for scientific recognition of homeopathy then still to make the appropriate choice of the remedy more easy

As far as your article on epigenetics is concerned , this is exactly what i was talking about in the attachment i send you on the work of the Dr Degroote. Here he very often administers nosodes to prevent the expression of miasmatic genes , the need to use these is determined with the energetic examination

greetings

Dr Med Alain Neckebroek

————————————-

First of all I congratulate you & your team members without the efforts of which it is mot possible to furnish this hpathy ezine issue2006. i very much impressed after reading the following articles significantly:
Your interview with Isaac Golden regarding Homoeoprofilaxis.
The choice of potency and the dose by David Little.
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome & Homoeopathy.
The remedy Cocculus ind. as described by Dr. Sunil Anand in very elaborative way to give the clear perception .
The well explained case of Cerebrospinal accident by Dr. Narangin Pai & Dr. Naveen Paskar. How intellengently they come to the conclusion to cure the case. I appriciate .
Such type of topics and cases definitly help and increase knowledge of the homoeopathic brethren.
Thanks for your untirely efforts.
Happy good wishes for the coming new year 2007.
Dr.Ranjit Singh

————————————-

Dear Manish,

Regarding some people fighting with the growth of Homeopathy that is just a small picture of an old debate about our origins. Many people accept with ease our DNA origins and are not happy with the divine one. Isnt that so strange?
Regarding epigenetics, I am sure many things can be found there, but as discussed few times, in my opinion the most part of the Vital Force is virtual and impossible to be seen in a common logical way using any present or future ways of measuring things.

There is no compromise I am sure, we just need to take things from a certain level and improve them in all ways from there above. Any microscopical investigations will have their own range of failure as the macroscopical model has.
That does not mean I am against scientifical thinking. I just emphasize the very limits of such thinking in describing the infinite.

Best for all of you,
Remus Mihaila

————————————-

dear sir,
thanks for your mail.my feedback is that it will be valuable to all homeopath and also it give new ideas to handle the cases and to our knowledge too.
dr.somanath addya

————————————-

I loved the article on the science behind homeopathy. It really helped me break my father’s strictly mathematical mind. I wish I had known earlier about the benefits of homeopathy for mental health since I wasted 8 yeras of life on a wrongful ezquizofrenia diagnosis only to find out I was a troubled Ind. adolescent with depression and psicosis. Luckly I decided to defy science and quit drugging myself about two months ago. Everyone disagreed, my psyquiatrist included but he just recently aproved my motion and I am no longer on medication. This was my third psyquiatrist and the only one who told me I did not have squitzofrenia but psychotic depression. I even went to Mclean Hospital before him where their final decision was neither to deny nor afirm that I did or did not have squitzofrenia. Thanks to GOD I know live a drug free and happy life. Please keep sending the newest on homeopathy. Thank you and goodbye.
alejandro berliner

————————————-

Before this I never knew what is acidity and gastric trouble is like. Even though I am practicing homoeopathy since 21 years and have treated thousands of patients suffering from Acidity and Gastric trouble, I myself never experienced this problem in my life before. But, this record of 46 years had to come to an end and it happened on 26th december 2006, when suddenly I felt that my chest is clutched by a fist and the congestion in heart was so severe that I almost stooped while walking, with this I had the electric like shocks which I felt in the region of heart. Even though I had lot of upper eructations, but no relief. I tried all sorts of homeopathic medicines that suited my case, example: asafoetida, bryonia, carbo-veg and many more, but my distress will not go. While going through Boerick and Dewey 12 tissue remedies I found Natrum phos to be matching my symptoms, and it was already 3 days since I suffered with this trouble(Making me completely unfit to go to my clinic) Believe me, the pain in the chest left me within 10 minutes of taking the first dose of Natrum phos 6x and the shocks stopped when I followed Natrum phos with Silicea. I was astonished to see the result with biochemic medicines. As today is the second day of my treatment I have just now taken the 4rth dose of the above said prescription and feeling as light as a flower while writing this to you) For your information I have more often applied biochemic remedies in my practice and 8 out of 10 cases I prescribe biochemic medicines and whenever I use biochemic medicines they never disappoint me and I get the desired results. I was very confident of this tissue system but after I got relief I am sure biochemic medicines are a system in itself and needs no other suplements. By this statement, I am not underestimating homoeopathy, but underlining the importance of Biochemic medicines in our practice.
Thank you,

Dr.Muhammad Mujahid Ahmed
BANGALORE.

————————————-

Dear Manish Bhatia,
Let me wish you and all the readers of your valued and esteemed homoeopathic e-mail journal, happy, healthy and prosperous New Year 2007. I pray for all
“Sarve Bhavantu Sukhinah
Sarve Santu Niramaya
Sarve Bhadrani Pasyantu
Ma Kashchid Dukh Bhaag Bhaveit”
So for my review of your journal is concerned, I shall like to say that it contains every thing such as philosophy and organon, Materia medica, clinical cases, and what not. It makes the reader to read the journal from beginning to end. But still I desire to add in the journal that (1)selection of potency, (2) repetition of medicines, (3) how to handle emergency cases like pain, fever, vomiting, diarrhea, and dysmenorrhea etc. According to me our brethren doctors
are confused and pharmaceutical companies are exploiting this situation.They are promoting specific combinations for the same.We , experience doctors, in the field should suggest some group of medicines which is specific for the situation on the bed side, such as neuralgic pain in the ear use plantago Q or vebescum Q with out any detail inquiry and i find that 70% to 80% case get relief immediately and other medicines are Chamomile, belledonna and pulsatilla with this group of medicines the doctor can handle most of the cases and gain reputation. Similarly for tooth ache plantago, belledonna or chamomile can be used. So bed side prescription is a must instead of combinations of medicines. once i used Aconite 10M for sudden heart attack at mid night and got appreciations. I feel that such type of experience should be shared.
Thanks for taking pains for compelling me to give my view, other wise I would have not given my view because I know that our experienced doctor have no time to share their view with fellow doctors and are involved only in politics and fond of chairs and claiming to represent homoeo community at large. They have divided the homoeo community and have done harm to it. I again thanks you for uniting homoeo community.
With warm regards.
Dr.S.C.Kursija

——————————————

Dear Dr.Manish,
I really thank you and the team for publishing Hpathy.com’s e-magazine. I decided to study Homeopathy seriously thourgh a college two years back. i have completed two years of four year course from Bay of Plenty college of Homeopathy in New Zealand.

I suggested a patient who was diagnosed to be suffering from HypoKalemia and was admitted to hospital and was being given potassium intravenously, a combination of all tissue salts containing Potassium. She recovered in just half a day, returned to normalcy. When it occurred a second time after few years, found that just Kali Sulph 3X alone fixed the same condition and she returned to normalcy in a day.

I appreciate all your articles, the interviews with more experienced people in hot chair etc. Most of all what attracts me is that it is all being done without profit motive. I hope to join and contribute more once i qualify to practice after two more years of study. I have seen many cases where homeopathy has helped and the controversial articles in Lancet or Dr.Randy’s challenges do not mean anything to me, but they arouse in me a spirit of challenge and am committed to find out how homeopathic remedies work. Untill it is found out(by anyone), i would not cease to help people to get well using Homeopathy. Just want to say, you are doing such a good job. Please keep it up. You will see many smiles in response to your good effort.
yours sincerely
Ramana

—————————————————

really it was a fantastic article but what id like to say that it isnt possible that we show cases to those people who r not believing in hpathy n than we show scientifically proof bcoz if in our field we r solving any cases by different doctor than our remedy also dfrnt so y this i hope u ll give me reply thanks
vimal ramani

—————————————————–

As a new student to homeopathy I am awed at the power of this medicine and I love discovering it through these articles.
Keep up the great work.
lpmoyer

—————————————-

DEAR SIR,

KIND REGARDS.

I AM NO DOCTOR, NOR HAVE STUDIED HOMOEOPATHY THROUGH AMY MEDICAL COLLEGE.

WHAT I HAVE DONE, HOWEVER, IS READ SEVERAL BOOKS ON H… KENT, TYLER, TSIYER, THE ULMANS, PATHAK, MATHUR,… EVEN HAHNEMANN HIMSELF.

I TURNED TO H AFTER A HOMOEOPATH MADE A MESS OF THE TWO SMALL DRY ECZEMA PATCHES I HAD ON MY ANKLES, THE SIZES OF A RUPEE COIN. AFTER CHECKING MY ARMS ETC FOR CHILDHOOD VACCINATION AND INJECTION SCARS, HE OPINED THAT I COULD BE SUFFERING FROM VACCINOSIS OR A TUBECULAR TAINT BY WAY OF HEREDITARY ENDOWMENT.

SO HE GAVE ME BACCILINUM 1000, SULPHUR 1000, AND PETROLEUM1000, TO BE TAKEN 5PILLS, THREE TIMES A DAY FOR 10-12 DAYS, WITH 2-3 WEEKS GAP IN BETWEEN.

BAC DID NOT DO ANYTHING VISIBLE, BUT WHEN I FINISHED WITH SUL, THE AGGRVN WAS SO BAD, I LOST THE SKIN ON BOTH FEET AND LARGE AREAS TURNED WEEPY, OOZING PUS AND BLOOD. THIS WENT ON FOR ~ 14 MONTHS. THE DOC EXPRESSED HIS HELPLESSNESS, SO I HAD TO TURN TO ANOTHER HOMOEOPATH, WHO WAS ALSO IN NO WAY HELPFUL.
THAT IS WHEN I BEGAN READING H BOOKS AND USING GRAPHITES OINT AND PILLS, I MANAGED TO GET THE PATCHES TO DRY AND GOT SKIN COVER, ALTHOUGH IT IS STILL FAR FROM ORIGINAL IN TEXTURE OR LOOK, DESPITE AROUND EIGHT YEARS HAVING PASSED. MY PATCHES HAVE DRIED, BUT CURE IS NOT COMPLETE YET, WITH ITCHING AND CONTINUANCE OF THE LESIONS.

MY EXPERIENCE HAS BEEN THAT THERE ARE STILL A LOT OF DIFFERENCES IN OPINION WHEN IT COMES TO ISSUES LIKE PRIORITY RANKINGS OF SYMPTOMS, POTENCY OF MEDICINES TO BE PRESCRIBED, DURATION OF TREATMENT, THE DIET STRICTURES AND SO ON.
IF ALL THESE ARE WELL DEFINED, IT’D MAKE HOMOEO TREATMENT THAT MUCH MORE EASIER!

-francis fernandes

—————————————-

Dear Sir:

I have read Grant Bentley’s book on facial analysis, Appearance and Circumstance, and recently purchased the accompanying handbook. I agree that genetic miasm can be indicated by body analysis. However, the miasm active in the patient at the time is always indicated by the present day symptoms, so it is necessary to keep this in mind. For example, sycosis may be the very active miasm, despite strong indications for the syphilis miasm in inheritance. So at the moment, that is what needs to be treated, while keeping in mind the need for the syphilitic miasm may soon rear its head. I did find the personality descriptions in the book very interesting.

Eileen Klinck

—————————————-

Homeo article re case Rt. C.V.A.

I really appreciated the case presented , the acute management , the investigations, the evaluation s and follow-ups and the choosing of constitutional remedy.It was extremely well organized, concise and demonstrated the amazing power and beauty of homeopathy in the treatment of an acute situation which would be normally treated in an Allopathic Hospital .Thank you.

V. Oberoi
————————————–
Choice of potency&dose
Dr. B
It is really a good and very useful topic for true Homoeopathic practitioners.
We need much more topics,to do successful practice.
Thank you.

with regards
Dr.A.Thirumala reddy
—————————————–
Just wondering if anyone else has had such superb results after using belladona as my son.

Initially consulted Homeopath (for the first time ever)when my son was almost three (now twenty two). He’d been on a continuous stream of antibiotics almost since birth but from the moment belladonna given, outstanding results achieved.

When aged twelve, my son’s hyperactive behaviour became v. difficult to handle. As a last resort, decided to contact Homeopath again but assumed there was nothing she could do to help. She prescribed belladonna again and to this day (10 years later) I and anyone else close to him, are amazed by the results. He is normally happy and focused but sometimes will be irritable, awkward and disorganised etc. but after just one belladonna will become extremely focused, organised and much happier.

We believe without belladona he would have dropped out of school and certainly would not have ended up with a good degree and doing well in life generally.

Has anyone else heard of belladona producing such profound results?

I would also like to know if there are any long term side effects from taking belladona. I would say during an average year he takes 4 – 6 tablets.
K Edwards
————————————-
Dear Dr.Manish Bhatia ,
This is my first online test. I was much worried as if it will be hard to write. But i enjoyed
about the test. Also i read more from the course. Its very clear as if a tutor was near me to teach. Thank You of this work. Awaitng more courses from you.
Very neatly designed lessons containing important points to remember.Answered well for the
queries. I learned some more points from the lessons.
Once again i Thank You for the work.
SUHANTHI SELVARAM.
——————————————-
is a wonderful page. I have a gripe with the individual pages on diseases that it links to: Please please have someone go through and format it so that all remedies are capitalized and italicized properly. See, in the middle of, say, the paragraph following the header “Gelsemium” you might find another remedy named and characterized as well. This is going to pose a problem for less=experienced prescribers, or those, who like me are trying to find a colic remedy for a screaming infant on her lap at 4 in the morning. The change-remedy-under-discussion=midstreamm detail might escape one less astute, and cause a misprescription. Thanks.
Nicole
—————————————-
Hi Dr. Manish Bhatiya,
Thanks for your wishes. Wishing you too, ” Happy and prosperous new year.”
I appreciate the work you are doing. The website is very informative and journal too. I met my friend through one of 2006 Dec articles – Dr.Niranjan Pai . I would appreciate if you can give me his email address or just forward mine to him. I would love to talk to him.
Thanks.
Best wishes for your work.
Yours,
Dr.Soniya Gandhi.

—————————————-

magnetic photons detected in homeopathic potencies

I would like a discussion on the following issues but was unable to put it into the discussion page. Could the editor please help.
Having proved that remedies are magnetic photons, similar to biophotons of 220-550 nanometers, how should the following issues be solved or deduced before further experiments:
1. To reuse a glass bottle for a different remedy or a remedy of higher or lower potency, is it enough and effective to remove all traces of magnetic photons by heating the empty bottle or placing it in the sun for >48 hours upside down?
2. Would combination remedies work as well, with different remedy or remedy of different potency work, as if the different magnetic photons are taken at the same time?
3.Some experts say , from experience that remedies are so powerful that any remedy in water will change the container as well. Does the magnetic photon theory account for this?
Candi

—————————————-

Dear Mr. Manish,

I have read your articles Homeopathy is Alive & Kicking! I really agree with you. Nowadays too many things are changing too many fast. Besides it is badly necessary to come together of Practice, theory & research.

Your know in medical sector even Bangladesh has invested a huge money in Alopathy Medicine.

I inspire you to go ahead about research in Homeopathy please.
Thanks & best regards,

Mamun
—————————————-

I’ve just located your site and it is lovely! I’d like to add my name to the Directory of Homeopaths. I practice in Winnipeg. What’s the next step?

Talk soon,
Cass

—————————————-

Dr.Isaac Golden’s revelation about the damage done by vaccination and his designing a 5-year program for homeoprophylaxis are interesting.His plan of using various potencies seems very sound.His struggle against orthodox allopathic as well as homeopathic opposition is admirable.You have obliged us by interviewing such a great homeo-researcher.
HARISH NAGPAL
—————————————-

Wishing Happy New Year to the respected Editor and his unique effort in providing us this wonderful service free of any charge!I endorse the view that homeopathy is growing rapidly despite underhand methods of opposition by jealous Allopaths.The scientific basis and convincing results of this noble pathy are too evident to be ignored.
HARISH NAGPAL

———————————————

THANK YOU ALL FOR YOUR FEEDBACK

Send us your feedback, views, comments and suggestions about various articles published in Homeopathy for Everyone and Hpathy.com in general to Dr. B at [email protected]. Your feedback is very important to us!

RELATED POSTS

About the author

Hpathy

Hpathy

This article and all other content at Hpathy.com is copyright protected by Hpathy.com. Any unauthorized copying to other websites or journals is not permitted. See the full Copyright Notice and Disclaimer at Hpathy.com

Leave a Comment