Cancer & Tumors Homeopathy Papers

Cancer and the Cancer Miasm

Last modified on August 11th, 2018

Katja Schuett
Written by Katja Schuett

This article describes the vitalistic concept of disease and cancer, its multifactorial etiologies and predisposing factors, cancer themes and personality, and curability, as well as the cancer miasm with its features, activating factors and symptoms.

Cancer

Cancer is a class of diseases in which a group of cells displays uncontrolled growth, and which is characterized by invasion due to intrusion on and destruction of adjacent tissues, and sometimes metastasis, i.e., cells spreading to other locations in the body via the lymph channels or blood-stream. These three malignant properties of cancers differentiate them from benign tumors, which are self-limited, and do not invade or metastasize. Most cancers form a tumor but some, like leukemia, do not.

One of the important tasks of the immune system is to identify and eliminate tumor cells. Tumor antigens are produced in tumor cells and trigger an immune response in the host. If functioning properly then these antigens appear foreign and cause immune cells to attack and destroy them by using killer T cells and T helper cells. If, however, the immune system no longer attacks them, tumor cells go on to become cancer.

Based on Virchow’s model of cellular pathology, orthodox medicine considers cancer to be first a local process, which then generalizes and invades the body. Therefore, the therapeutic intervention is directed at the removal and destruction of the lesion by means of aggressive treatment such as surgery, chemotherapy and radiation.

The homeopathic perception of cancer is based on a vitalistic approach. Hahnemann clearly stated that life is impossible without the vital force, and referred all the phenomena of health, disease and cure under the names of ‘the dynamis’ and ‘the vital force’.

The vital force is universally present, spiritual and instinctual in nature. It is present everywhere in the organism, embracing the whole person in mind, body and spirit. The vital force is the source of human life and the level at which the causation of diseases originates. Its derangement is the very beginning of the disorder and causes changes in sensations and functions long before there is any visible change in the material substance of the body.

When man falls ill it is at first only this self-sustaining spirit-like vital force (vital principle) everywhere present in the organism which is mistuned by the dynamic influence of the hostile disease agent. It is only this vital force thus mistuned which brings about in the organism the disagreeable sensations and abnormal functions that we call disease.” §11 Organon

The vital force is invisible. Its derangement can only be seen by signs and symptoms, whose totality represents the entire extent of the sickness and constitutes their true and only conceivable form. The inability of the vital force to maintain its equilibrium as a consequence of a particular stimulus leads to the alteration in the normal functions of body and mind, and creates mental, emotional and physical symptoms. When the totality of symptoms is removed the disease ceases to exist.

Thus health and disease are only different states of the vital force, and disease is not an entity separated from the living organism. Disease always progresses from functional disturbances to structural changes, and from slight to deep pathological manifestations in the most predisposed regions of the body. Thus, clinical pathological manifestations are only the last stage of the developing disease process, and cancer is not a local disease but a localized expression of the dynamic disease that encompasses the whole subject. A general chronic state always precedes the appearance of cancer.

“The man who believes that he is directing his remedies against germs, or against worms, or against a tumor the patient may have, is in extreme darkness, if he cannot perceive that a healthy man will have healthy tissue, healthy blood, and therefore there can be no soil for germs and worms or morbid growth.” J. T. Kent

As the vital force is the level at which disease originates, and the healing power of nature, it is obvious, that only therapies which are able to rebalance the disturbed vital force, can go back to the very origin of the disease and provide a real cure. Balancing the vital force means regaining and maintaining harmony within the body. Back to its equilibrium, the vital force can rule again with unbounded sway and assert its influence on the organism, allowing the process of physis to move in its natural direction towards normal homeostasis.

The mere removal or destruction of the cancer neither affects the vital process which lead to its manifestation, nor does it touch the patient’s predisposition towards cancerous diseases, which is why the tumor can recur elsewhere and even be more malignant than before.

“The surgical removal of tumors seems to me to be unsatisfactory in every important particular. It only professes to deal with the produce and can never be, even theoretically, a Hunterian cure: the disposition is not even aimed at ! The treatment by the actual cautery gets rid of the superficial effect – the product – the cause is not even considered at all.” J. C. Burnett

The weakening and suppression of the vital force plays an important part in the etiology of cancer growth, just as much as in any other chronic condition. Hahnemann made it very clear: When a chronic disease is deprived of local manifestations, it must take another and more serious form.

“The more profound the suppression, the larger and deeper the new manifestation or disease process. Each subsequent suppression includes more vital centers or organs … In this way abnormal growth appears or a new disease process develops, which is being classified as a new disease by pathologists.” J. H. Allen


“These chronic miasmatic diseases, if deprived of their local symptom, are inevitably destined by mighty Nature sooner or later to become developed and to burst forth, and thereby propagate all the nameless misery, the incredible number of chronic diseases which have plagued mankind for hundreds and thousands of years, none of which would so frequently have come into existence had physicians striven in a rational manner to cure radically and to extinguish in the organism these three miasms by the internal homeopathic medicines suited for each of them, without employing topical remedies for their external symptoms.” §204 Organon

In this way pathological manifestations changed over the years and became much more severe. As the chronic miasms become activated at a much earlier age and increasingly concentrated in each generation, the incidence of cancer is becoming more widespread and develops now even at a very young age.

Cancer, however, is not the same as the cancer miasm. Cancer can occur from any miasmatic constellation. With the cancer miasm, however, all four basic miasms are active. Depending on the patient’s miasmatic constellation the cancer will display different characteristics and have a different prognosis.

Psora dominant active miasm:

  • Psora is the fundamental, underlying cause for all diseases and miasms

  • It is responsible for deficiency which leads to hypo-immunity

  • The lowered immunity makes the person susceptible to continuous physical and/or emotional irritation which may finally lead to the development of cancer

  • It provides the irritation as a factor for the development of cancer

  • Continued local irritation slackens the cell-controlling power to its utmost capacity until it ultimately snaps and breaks

  • Especially general irritations of various kinds, such as mental strain, anxieties, worries, excess of work etc.

  • The greater the general irritation or strain, the less local irritation is necessary to break the cell control

  • Slowly growing tumors are characteristic

  • They are often benign

  • Patients with a predominantly psoric cancer can live a long time

  • Burnett points out the detrimental effect of suppressing skin diseases and silencing cutaneous discharges for the development of tumors and cancer [1]

Sycosis dominant active miasm:

  • Sycosis stimulates proliferation, hypertrophy and overgrowth

  • These tumors may be benign and encapsulated in the beginning, but become malignant as the cells proliferate out of proportion

  • Rapidly growing tumors are characteristic

  • J.H. Clarke opines that sycosis seems to favor surface tumors, and that the gouty diathesis in particular seems to favor tumor formation of the epithelial type [2]

  • J.H. Allen warns that the suppression of sycotic skin diseases favors the development of cancer, especially when psora was strong or the tubercular miasm present [3]

Syphilis dominant active miasm:

  • Syphilis is responsible for destruction, cell breakdown, disintegration and degeneration

  • Syphilis contributes the destructive component with the necrotic, degenerative growth and ulceration of the cancer

  • It has far-reaching effects, perhaps especially selecting the harder tissues and the nervous system

  • The malignant property of the cells leads to necrosis followed by pus formation and fistulous openings in the tumor

  • Cancers based on genetic mutation are syphilitic

  • Cancer spreads quickly after the onset of some little pain, demonstrating the destruction and hiding of the syphilitic miasm, and rapid growth of sycosis

Tubercular dominant active miasm:

  • Adds an aggressive component, and the nodular and degenerative tubercles that may lead to cancer of the lung or at other sites

  • It is responsible for migration and hemorrhage; the disintegrated and degenerated cells hemorrhage and then migrate resulting in metastasis

  • Seems to lead chiefly to the connective tissue type of tumor according to J.H. Clarke [2]

Examples for different miasmatic constellations in cancer:

Scirrhus: psora-sycosis-syphilis (lethal activity, but less cruel than others)

Adenoma: sycosis-psora-syphilis (more malignant)

Sarcomatous cancer: syphilitic-sycotic-psoric (more profound, destructive, violent and terrible)

Cancer diathesis

A patient will have a certain tendency to cancer when he displays the following general characteristics:

  • when there are any cancer cases in the parents or family

  • especially predisposing to malignancy is when there was syphilis or gonorrhea

  • repeated vaccinations and suppressions

  • when the patient had a period of marked weakness, general or localized atony in the susceptible area

  • hepatic insufficiency

  • a general state of intoxication

  • Eli G. Jones points out the correlation between the increase in cancer and the excessive consumption of meat (animal proteins), tea, coffee, and alcohol (stimulants that weaken the nervous system)

Cancer has a strong mental-emotional component due to the strong connection between the mental and emotional life and the immune system

  • when a person suffered a difficult traumatic or unhappy childhood and/or physical, mental and sexual abuse

  • when there had been problems in the parent-child relationship that led to a feeling of loneliness, neglect, rejection, resentment

  • when the subject has a sense of low self-image, lack of confidence, a feeling of unworthiness and never been loved, deep despondency and despair

  • cancer may develop after a long destructive attitude towards life, inner hurts, long lasting grief, unhappy love, and a feeling of being misunderstood
  • a predisposition to cancer is set by unhappiness

  • a disturbed mental state through the morbid fear of cancer

  • anxieties and worries

  • when he reacts adversely or is unable to cope adequately with stress

  • a severe fateful or negative event or trauma often preceeds the onset of developing cancer, and comes as a “last straw” on top of years of unhappiness or suppressed reactions to stress

Cancer themes and personality

  • the overwhelming high degree of cell division, with need for control in order to survive

  • feeling of chaos, disorder, and of losing control

  • need for self control and to restore order

  • little chance of success but some hope [8]

  • expected to fulfill a great demand which he is incapable of doing

  • making superhuman efforts and stretching oneself beyond the limits of his capacity in order to survive

  • failure is death and destruction

  • continuous and prolonged struggle which seems to have no end

  • cancer people are a model of perfection, one with whom it is easy to get along and difficult to find faults

  • no rest or freedom from tension

  • try hard to please others

  • high level of performance

  • often had demanding parents, who set up high expectations, demanded quality and achievements, and were moralizing and ethical

  • or have a history of lack of closeness with one or both parents, or a lack of closeness with spouse or others who would normally be close

  • in today’s competitive world cancer is showing up in greater frequency as a sign of the desperate struggle to survive

Curability

The size or stage of cancer does not necessarily indicate its curability. Curability is the capability of being healed. It has a different scope depending on the system of medicine being used.

In homeopathy cure goes beyond the mere removal of clinical manifestations. It consists in reestablishing the energetic equilibrium to which the disease is due, and the removal of the disease in its entire extent. Whereas allopathy only focuses on the pathological lesions in which the morbid process ultimates, homeopathy embraces the primary dynamic process of the disease, and the entire morbid process and its clinical manifestations.

Diseases are curable when they make themselves known in signs and symptoms. As long as characteristic signs and symptoms are present, good vital reaction continues and the patient will have the reactive ability to bring about a secondary curative reaction.

“All curable diseases make themselves known to the intelligent physician in signs and symptoms…To be able to perceive the remedy from the signs and symptoms in the present or history is one item of cure, but another and quite different item is the vital reaction of the patient.” J.T.Kent – Lesser Writings

Homeopathic treatment ensures best results when the patient is already treated in their precancerous state, before the appearance of cancer. Advanced cancer is most difficult to treat as the vital force decreases with increasing pathology, and in proportion as the pathology increases, the characteristic signs and symptoms decrease, rendering us unable to obtain a therapeutic individualization of symptoms. However, severely suppressive treatments of modern medicine, including radiation, chemotherapy and vaccinations, largely contributed to the weakening of the vital force and make the successful homeopathic treatment of cancer much more difficult than at times when the old masters like Hahnemann, Boenninghausen, Grimmer, Schlegel or Burnett, etc. were treating cancer patients.

Cancer Miasm or Cancerism

The term “miasm” is derived from the Greek meaning “pollution” or “taint”. In homeopathic terms it is an invisible polluting substance, a noxious influence, or the infectious principle, which after entrance in the organism overpowers the vital force and sets up a specific disease. Miasms are dynamic, disease-producing factors and the source of suffering and death.

Hahnemann distinguished between acute, half-acute and chronic miasms. True chronic miasms modify the course of acute diseases and establish a permanent field for chronic diseases. They arise from contagion, which creates the miasmatic state, or diathesis, and forms a chronic predisposition to a characteristic form of disease both in respect to dysfunctions and to the lesions themselves. The vital force is unable to eradicate chronic miasms, even not with the most robust constitution, healthiest life-style or best diet.

“The absolute of the disease is the miasmatic impact.” J.H.Allen

Based on chronic miasms the patient passes through states of illnesses with a characteristic connecting link. However, despite the collective picture of the chronic miasms, each patient displays their own individual symptom pattern. Each patient has a combination of all miasms, but the proportion of the miasms differs in each individual in quantity and degree. One miasm may clearly predominate, but it may also be observed that the predominant symptoms correspond to more than one miasm. So even if the person’s attitude, appearance and symptoms corresponds more to one of the fundamental miasms, he will have certain traits and manifestations of the other.

Hahnemann defined three primary chronic miasms; Psora, Sycosis and Syphilis, after having found patterns of these diseases in the patients and their family histories after twelve years of research into unsolved chronic cases.

Although the tubercular miasm resembles symptoms of psora and syphilis, and was assigned to psora by homeopaths like Kent and Close, it is meanwhile widely recognized as a separate miasm, due to its distinct characteristic features. As with psora, sycosis and syphilis, the tubercular miasm also has a related micro-organism in the primary stage of the chronic disease. [4]

Although Hahnemann found three miasms to be prevalent in Europe he did not limit the number of miasms, and there are other conditions which meet the criteria of chronic miasms.

The cancer miasm is usually defined as a miasmatic constellation in which all four basic miasms are active.

Despite the connection of certain viral diseases such as mononucleosis, hepatitis, herpes zoster, clamydia, HPV, etc., and the development of cancer, the cancer miasm has not been proven so far to be based on contagion like Hahnemann’s original miasms.

Notwithstanding its origin it causes life-long suffering, sets up a certain dyscrasia or diathesis, has a particular pattern with distinct pathological tendencies and is transmitted to subsequent generations. Many severe ailments met with in practice are often linked to the Cancer miasm. Cancer can arise from any miasmatic constellation, but the possibility of developing it increases when all four miasms are active.

The cancer miasm represents the greatest restriction in the free movement of the basic forces essential for health. It is placed towards the end of the disease process, reflecting the evolution of mankind through miasms that have become increasingly more degenerative, and resulting in most severe, complicated and dangerous disease states.

Chronic miasms are collective disorders with similar symptoms that affect a homogeneous group. Hence, the miasms the individual suffers from are not isolated from the human race but connected to their collective miasms, which represent the way individuals and humanity as a collective evolve and learn through disease and imbalance. The analysis of humanity in different ages reveals a clearly predominant miasm, which is “dominating any given human group or nation as well as its rules, philosophies, politics and collective happenings“[5]. Whereas psora was the predominant miasm at Hahnemann’s time in Europe, sycosis prevailed during the last decades, with Cancerism now coming more and more to the fore.

Last but not least working through and beyond the miasms is part of our karma. The nature of the miasm characterizes not only symptoms and diseases, but they also offer different karmic choices and “represent key issues or learning experiences which impede humanity’s progress in its struggle toward spiritual evolution and enlightenment.”[6] The cancer miasm offers us the ultimate choice of accepting change as a positive force or of living in a state of complete stasis induced by the fear of change as an inevitable negative influence.[7]

The cancer miasm was not identified until after the Second World War. Dr. Foubister and Dr. Templeton, two homeopaths working in England at that time, observed the appearance of similar symptoms in children born to mothers suffering from breast cancer during pregnancy. Symptoms were insomnia, weakness, sensitivity, crying all night, moles, blue sclerae, cafe au lait spots on the skin, tics and blinking of the eyes. These children were supposed to carry the cancer miasm and were successfully treated with Carcinosin. Children born with similar symptoms also received Carcinosin either to treat or protect them from cancer in future, and hundreds of cases were collected. Therefrom a materia medica for Carcinosin was written containing mainly clinical symptoms. Provings were only made later, so that this remedy does not appear in older repertories.

Suppression on all levels is the central idea of the cancer miasm and the major etiological factor contributing to the lack of reactivity, weakening of the vital force, and an undeveloped, misfunctioning or destroyed immune system. An active cancer miasm does not necessarily mean that one will have or develop cancer. But often a traumatic event eventually triggers the formation of cancer, as often occurring 2-5 years after a mental or physical trauma.

Features according to Dr. Sankaran

Depth, pace and perception

About the author

Katja Schuett

Katja Schuett

Katja Schutt, Msc, HP, DHM, PGHom, DVetHom, has studied homeopathy with several schools, amongst which David Little’s advanced course stands out as it offers a really deep insight into homeopathic philosophy and materia medica (simillimum.com). Her current focus lies in working with animals and studying history, the old masters, and research.

12 Comments

  • DEAR DR
    WE DO NOT KNOW IN EACH CASE AS TO WHAT IS RATIO OF MIASMS IN THE PATIENT. WE MAY WITHOUT GIVING CANCER NOSODES AVAILABLE INSTEAD WE SHOULD PREPARE A NOSODE FROM OBTAINING A MATERIAL FROM THE BODY OF THE PATIENT ITSELF AND PREPARE A NOSODE AND USE IT IN HIGHER AND HIGHER POTENCY. I HOPE THIS WILL CURE HIM MORE RAPIDLY. I WILL BE GREATFUL IF DOCTORS TREATING THE CANCER PATIENTS GIVE ME THEIR PRACTICAL VIEWS
    THANKS
    DR SHEKHAR

  • Dear Author,
    In no way it is helpful to practitioner without the examples of treated cases.Homeopathy is a triangle approach such as patient, pathology and the symptomatology, the third dimension which completes the TRIANGLE.This third dimension is the key-dimension which can be had from a treated cases.The secret of success lies only on the third dimension.So please in future present papers with some examples.
    Thanks for your good paper presentation.
    ganesan.m

  • Hello,,,sir,
    your article is very nice for cancer…but i have seen no peoples accept homeopathy treatment who get cancer,,,,i want to read one article about spinal canal stenosis (lower lumbar)(problem ,when i walk i get numness in both legs,tingling,,etc.),if you give articles on above subject,,,i will thankfull to you.

  • dear katja, very well written article. could I have your permission to share it with students I am teaching. thanks. kathleen raskin

  • Dear Dr.Katja Schütt,

    I am a originally a Pharmacologist and am now an ardent believer
    in homeopathy. Besides I am a voracious reader of medical articles
    on dozens of websites both related to allopathic remedies and
    homeopathy.

    Reading you both the articles = the editorial and the cancer & Cancer
    and the Cancer Miasm, I got so engrossed in each word you say because
    apart from conveying the in depth understanding of the inherent link of
    illnesses with the body, your messages is coated with the total relationship with the God’s creation and the net effect of our loosing
    the very concept of the way our Creator created every process.
    As a result, we fall prey to our own conceptions and misconceptions ultimately effecting our body health.

    Pls accept my best wishes and regards

    MAN MOHAN DAS

  • hi, i really want to thank you, for this excellent article. since, i was finished my course 3 months back, i m fresh to practice homoeopathy,until now i didn’t see any other cancer cases , but this article will help me a lot in a later on .

  • Dear dr.
    Very informative article on cancer. i have not treated any cancer patient yet but now i can confidently deal with such cases.The basic guidelines given by you are enough to handle such cases efficiently.so i heartly thank you and congratulate you for such a wonderful article.
    Thank you.

  • Dear Katja,
    Please accept my heartiest congratulation for presenting this highly informative paper. In future it would be more interesting if u kindly add the

    A. Name of different types of cancers under different Miasms.
    B. Treated case reports.

    Thanks.

    AZIZ

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *